如果你想制作动画内容,有大量的软件和技术可以探索。两个流行的二维动画程序--Moho和Adobe Animate CC,有很多共同点,但在一些关键方面有所不同。
在这篇文章中,我们将看一下其中的区别,以便你能确定哪种方式更适合你的目标或工作方式。
换句话说。 Moho vs. Animate CC。你应该使用哪一个?
内容:
使用案例
Moho
Moho的最大特点是它易于使用,可以创建可重复使用的二维模型,并具有巨大的控制力。这使得它非常适用于电视节目、网络剧,甚至用于创建视频游戏动画。
Moho在其矢量装备的角色上全力以赴,而忽视了其他手绘功能。虽然它确实有做手绘动画的选项,但它非常有限。
虽然它不是一个行业标准的动画软件,但它已经被用于奥斯卡提名的故事片中。
Animate CC
Animate CC还提供了做手绘逐帧动画的能力(尽管Animate的绘图工具看起来或感觉不那么自然。
但Animate CC也使它很容易做有限的动画,其中角色的个别部分可以交换,还有木偶动画,其中角色装备可以摆放,而无需重新绘制。
除了逐帧动画之外,还可以选择使用这些节省时间的技术,这使得它更适合于预算较低、时间紧迫的制作,如电视和网络剧。
Animate CC,当它还叫Flash的时候,曾经是制作网络动画的唯一实用方法。现在,Animate的易用性和较低的入门门槛使它继续成为独立动画师为Youtube制作内容的首选。
使用Adobe Animate (Flash)的优酷网友。
艾伦-贝克尔 (查看他的动画课程)
拒绝接受
杰登动画
Adobe Animate也被用来制作电视动画。
使用Adobe Animate(Flash)制作的好看的节目。
Moho与Animate CC:主要区别
莫霍。
- 可重复使用的角色
- 时间紧凑的内容
- 强大的角色装置
Animate CC。
- 叙事动画
- 互动网络内容
- 木偶角色或手绘动画。
学习曲线
Moho
Moho为自己的直观性感到自豪,他们已经努力使索具成为一项不那么艰巨的任务,但要想最好地实现他们的工具,仍有很多东西需要学习。
虽然更简单的装置很容易设置,但你必须深入挖掘,使用其所有智能工具来创建更复杂的装置。
Animate CC
Adobe Animate通常被认为是同类动画程序中比较容易学习的一个。
为了最好地利用Animate的功能,有很多技术需要学习,基于矢量的绘图工具也需要一些时间来适应,但制作动画的基本界面和工作流程一般都很直观,很容易上手。
艺术工具
Moho
Moho专注于矢量绘图工具。虽然它确实有位图绘制功能,但你更有可能导入其他程序中绘制的位图作品。
你可能会用到的大部分工具都是索具工具,它们对矢量和位图艺术都很有效。
Animate CC
在绘画方面,Adobe Animate与TV paint非常相反。它有一系列矢量绘图工具,用于创建清晰的、可扩展的、文件大小较小的艺术作品,而且内存占用相对较少。
如果你习惯于使用Photoshop或Procreate等位图绘制软件来绘图,可能需要一些时间来适应。
如果你担心矢量工具对角色动画来说太过笨重,要知道Adobe Animate中的工具与Adobe Illustrator中的工具工作方式不同,例如,更适合于自由手绘。
动画功能
逐帧动画
如果你想拥有逐帧绘制动画的能力。 Animate CC绝对是你的首选。 Animate的核心是使用数字工具来创建单个的动画帧。
Moho确实有逐帧功能,不过这不是它的强项。
装配角色木偶
Moho的最大卖点是它的索具能力。它具有多种先进的索具工具,既可以实现直观的简单索具过程,也可以在需要时实现先进的复杂索具管道。
它独特的智能骨骼系统是制作感觉更像手绘的装备人物的最简单方法。
Animate CC的装置功能相当基本,但它们很容易使用,并相当快地构建一个你可以使用的角色。
其他因素
Moho有许多效果,可以应用于你的图层和绘图元素,让你做一些事情,如添加阴影和颜色修改。
由于不同的效果是在界面的不同地方应用的,所以要弄清楚如何实现你想要的效果可能是不直观的。许多效果不能在你的画布视图中实时渲染,所以你需要进行大量的预览渲染,以了解你的效果如何。
Animate CC区别于基本上任何其他动画软件的一大特点是,Animate具有为网络发布内容的能力。你可以使用Adobe Animate创建HTML5 Canvas、WebGL和SVG动画。
这包括制作互动性的动画,如广告或游戏。所以,如果这是你的目标,你应该选择Animate。
费用
Moho有两个版本。Moho Debut和Moho Pro。
Moho专业版是我们推荐使用的。使专业版值得升级的关键功能是Smart Bones和Smart Warp。这些工具使Moho的索具如此出色,强烈推荐。
还有像尺寸限制和3D对象支持,使Pro更适合做严肃的动画工作。
首次亮相 |
专业版 |
||
Moho |
$59.99 |
399.99美元/月 |
|
Animate CC只能通过Adobe的Creative Cloud订阅模式获取。Animate CC可以单独购买,也可以作为Adobe全软件包的一部分购买。
月度计划 |
年度计划(每月支付)。 |
年度计划(预付费) |
|
Animate CC |
31.49美元/月 |
20.99美元/月 |
239.88美元/年 |
所有的Adobe应用程序 |
79.49美元/月 |
52.99美元/月 |
599.88美元/年 |
Moho与Animate CC——你如何选择?
谁赢得了莫霍对阵Animate CC战斗?
选择Moho 如果你对做装配式木偶动画感兴趣,并希望能以低于平均水平的学习曲线取得令人印象深刻的、高于平均水平的效果,请选择Moho。
如果你想以简单的方式开始制作动画,或者如果你想通过采用有限的动画或木偶操纵的角色来节省时间和金钱,除了逐帧动画之外,请选择Animate CC。
让我们开始吧
Bloop为这两个程序提供了以动画为重点的课程,因此你可以跳进去,学习所有你需要知道的工具,开始制作动画。
In this post we’ll look at the differences so you can determine which better suits your goals or way of working.
In other words: Moho vs. Animate CC. Which one should you use?
内容:
Use Cases
Learning Curve
Art Tools
Animation Features
Cost
How to get started
Use Cases
Moho
The big hook of Moho is it’s ease of use for creating reusable 2D rigs with a tremendous amount of control. This makes it great for TV shows, web series and even for creating video game animation.
Moho goes all in on its vector rigged characters, and neglects other hand-drawn features. While it does have the option to do hand drawn animation, it’s very limited.
While it’s not an industry standard animation software, it has been used in Oscar nominated feature films:
Animate CC
Animate CC also offers the ability to do hand drawn frame-by-frame animation (though Animate’s drawing tools don’t look or feel as natural.
But Animate CC also makes it easy to do limited animation where individual pieces of the character can be swapped, and puppet animation where a character rig can be posed without redrawing it.
The option to use these time saving techniques in addition to frame-by-frame animation makes it much better suited to productions with a lower budget and tight schedule like TV and web series.
Animate CC, back when it was still called Flash, used to be the only practical way of creating animation for the web. Now, Animate’s ease of use and low barrier to entry continues to make it a goto for independent animators producing content for Youtube.
YouTubers who use Adobe Animate (Flash):
Alan Becker (Check out his animation course)
拒绝接受
杰登动画
Adobe Animate也被用来制作电视动画。
使用Adobe Animate(Flash)制作的好看的节目。
Moho vs. Animate CC: Main differences
Moho:
Reusable characters
Content with a very tight schedule
Powerful Character Rigs
Animate CC。
Narrative Animations
Interactive Web Content
Puppet Characters or Hand Drawn Animation.
Learning Curve
Moho
Moho prides itself for being intuitive, and they have made an effort to make rigging a much less daunting task, but there’s still a lot to learn to best implement their tools.
While the more simple rigs are easy to set up, you’ll have to dig deep to use all of its smart tools for creating more complex rigs.
Animate CC
Adobe Animate is generally considered one of the easier animation programs of it’s kind to learn.
There’s a lot of techniques to learn in order to best make use of Animate’s features, and the vector-based drawing tools will take some getting used to, but the basic interface and workflow for making animation is generally intuitive and easy to pickup.
Art Tools
Moho
Moho focuses on vector drawing tools. While it does have bitmap drawing capabilities, you’re more likely to import bitmap artwork drawn in another program.
Most of the tools you’ll probably use are the rigging tools, which work great for both vector and bitmap art.
Animate CC
Adobe Animate is very much the opposite of TV paint when it comes to drawing. It has a series of vector drawing tools for creating crisp, scalable, artwork with a low file size, and relatively low memory usage.
If you’re used to drawing with a bitmap drawing program like Photoshop or Procreate, it can take some getting used to.
If you’re afraid that vector tools are too clunky for character animation, know that tools in Adobe Animate work differently from those in Adobe Illustrator for example and are much better suited for free hand drawing.
Animation Features
Frame-by-Frame Animation
If you want the ability to draw animation frame-by-frame, Animate CC is definitely the way to go. Animate, at its core, is about using digital tools to create individual frames of animation.
Moho does have frame-by-frame capabilities, though it’s not its strong suit.
Rigging Character Puppets
Moho’s biggest selling point is its rigging capabilities. It features a wide variety of advanced rigging tools that allows for both an intuitive simple rigging process, and an advanced complex rigging pipeline if needed.
Its unique Smart Bone system is the easiest way to make rigged characters that feel more hand drawn.
The character rigging features of Animate CC are fairly basic, but it’s easy to start working with them and build a character you can work with fairly quickly.
Other Factors
Moho has many effects that can be applied to your layers and drawing elements that let you do things like add shadows and color modifications.
It can be unintuitive to figure out how to achieve the effect you’re going for since different effects are applied from different places in the interface. Many effects can’t be rendered live in your canvas view so you’ll need to do a lot of preview renders to see how your effects look.
One big feature that differentiates Animate CC from basically any other animation software, is that Animate has the ability to publish content for the web. You can create HTML5 Canvas, WebGL, and SVG animations using Adobe Animate.
This includes making animations with interactivity like for ads or games. So if that’s your goal you should go with Animate.
Cost
Moho is available in two versions: Moho Debut and Moho Pro.
Moho Pro is what we recommend using. The key features that makes the Pro version worth the upgrade are Smart Bones and Smart Warp. These tools are what makes Moho’s rigging so great, and are highly recommended.
There’s also things like size limits and 3D object support that make Pro much better suited for doing serious animation work.
首次亮相
专业版
Moho
$59.99
399.99美元/月
Animate CC只能通过Adobe的Creative Cloud订阅模式获取。Animate CC可以单独购买,也可以作为Adobe全软件包的一部分购买。
月度计划
年度计划(每月支付)
年度计划(预付)
Animate CC
31.49美元/月
20.99美元/月
239.88美元/年
所有的Adobe应用程序
79.49美元/月
52.99美元/月
599.88美元/年
Moho vs. Animate CC – How do you choose?
Who won the Moho vs. Animate CC fight?
Choose Moho if you’re interested in doing rigged-puppet animation and want to be able to achieve impressive, above average results with a below average learning curve.
Go with Animate CC if you want a simple way to get started with animation, or if you are looking for ways to save time and money by employing limited animation or puppet rigged characters in addition to frame-by-frame animation.
Get started
Bloop has animation-focused courses for both programs, so you can jump in and learn all the tools you need to know to get started animating.
Moho Animation CourseA step-by-step course to character animation with Moho.
Animate CC Animation CourseLearn how to make cool animations for YouTube, or 2D frame-by-frame animation for commercial use.
Character Animator Animation CourseLearn to animate animate in real-time, using your own face. No animation skills required.
After Effects Animation CourseA step-by-step course to character animation with After Effects.